Saturn Award

2003: Best Actress - Spiderman (nominated)
1996: Best Performance by a Younger Actor - Jumanji (nominated) 1995: Best Performance by a Younger Actor - Interview with the Vampire: The Vampire Chronicles (Won)

Blockbuster Entertainment Awards

2001: Favorite Actress - Bring It On (Nominated)

Boston Society of Film Critics Awards

1994: Best Supporting Actress - Interview with the Vampire: The Vampire Chronicles (Won)

Chicago Film Critics Association Awards

1995: Most Promising Actress - Interview with the Vampire: The Vampire Chronicles (Won)

Chlotrudis Awards

1995: Best Supporting Actress - Little Women (nominated)

DVD Exclusive Awards

2001: Best Actress - All Forgotten (nominated)

Empire Awards

2005: Best Actress - Spiderman 2 (nominated)
2003: Best Actress - Spiderman (Won)

Golden Globes

1995: Best Performance by an Actress in a Supporting Role in a Motion Picture - Interview with the Vampire: The Vampire Chronicles (nominated)

Kids’ Choice Awards

2008 Favorite Female Movie Star - Spiderman 3 (nominated)
2003: Favorite Movie Actress - Spiderman (nominated)

MTV Movie Awards

2003: Best Female Performance - Spiderman (Won)
2003: Best Kiss - Spiderman (Won)
1995: Best Breakthrough Performance - Interview with the Vampire: The Vampire Chronicles (Won)

Mar del Plata Film Festival

2002: Best Actress - The Cat’s Meow (Won)

People’s Choice Awards

2008: Favorite On Screen Match-up - Spiderman 3 (nominated)
2007: Favorite Leading Lady (nominated)
2005: Favorite On-Screen Chemistry - Spiderman 2 (nominated)

National Movie Awards, UK

2007: Best Performance by a Female - Spiderman 3 (nominated)

ShoWest Award

2007: Female Star of the Year (Won)

Teen Choice Awards

2007: Choice Movie Actress: Action Adventure - Spiderman 3 (nominated)
2007: Choice Movie: Liplock - Spiderman 3 (nominated)
2004: Choice Movie Sleazebag - Mona Lisa Smile (nominated)
2002: Film - Choice Lip Lock - Spiderman (Won)
2002: Film - Choice Actress, Drama/Action Adventure - Spider-Man (nominated)
2002: Film - Choice Chemistry - Spiderman (nominated)
2001: Film - Choice Actress - Bring It On (nominated)
2001: Film - Choice Chemistry - Get Over It (nominated)
2000: Film - Choice Actress - The Virgin Suicides (nominated)

Young Artist Awards

2001: Best Performance in a Feature Film - Leading Young Actress - Bring It On (nominated)
2000: Best Performance in a TV Movie or Pilot - Leading Young Actress - The Devil’s Arithmetic (nominated)
1999: Best Performance in a Feature Film - Leading Young Actress - Small Soldiers (nominated)
1998: Best Performance in a TV Movie/Pilot/Mini-Series - Leading Young Actress - Tower of Terror (nominated)
1997: Best Performance in a Drama Series - Guest Starring Young Actress - “ER” (nominated)
1996: Best Young Leading Actress - Feature Film - Jumanji (nominated)
1995: Best Performance by a Young Actress Co-Starring in a Motion Picture - Little Women (Won)

YoungStar Awards

2000: Best Young Actress/Performance in a Motion Picture Comedy - Dick (nominated)
2000: Best Young Actress/Performance in a Motion Picture Drama - The Virgin Suicides (nominated)
1998: Best Performance by a Young Actress in a Miniseries/Made-for-TV Movie - Fifteen and Pregnant (Won)
1997: Best Performance by a Young Actress in a Made For TV Movie for: The Siege at Ruby Ridge (Won)
1997: Best Performance by a Young Actress in a Drama TV Series - “ER” (nominated)
1995: Best Performance by a Young Actress in a Drama Film - Interview with the Vampire: The Vampire Chronicles - Little Women (Won)